Tilly's Pub Menu (2025 Update)
Welcome to Tilly's Pub, a hidden gem nestled in Clearwater Crossing, Indianapolis. This charming pub features a diverse menu that caters to all tastes, making it the perfect spot to unwind with friends or family. The heart of Tilly's menu lies in its delectable sandwiches and hearty salads.
- Sandwiches: Try the Chicken Breast, available either breaded or grilled, paired with your choice of side for just $6.95. Don't miss the signature Hollye's Cowboy Burger, a flavor-packed delight topped with crispy onion straws at $7.95.
- Salads: For something lighter, the Chef Salad, loaded with fresh ingredients including ham and bacon for $8.95, is a crowd favorite.
With sides like creamy Cole Slaw and savory Hush Puppies, Tilly's Pub ensures every meal is memorable. Whether you're popping in for a quick lunch or a leisurely dinner, Tilly's promises comfort food that truly satisfies.
Appetizers
Tilly's Famous Smelt Basket
a steaming basket of deep-fried smelt served with your choice of dipping sauce
Queso Dip
spicy and cheesy - enough to share! served with tortilla chips
Spinach Artichoke Dip
a creamy dip loaded with spinach and bits of artichoke. served with tortilla chips
Chicken Quesadilla
stuffed with chicken, cheese, onions and roasted red peppers. served with sour cream and salsa
Wild Bill Wings
8 wings served with celery and carrot sticks. choose hot, mild, medium, or bbq
Poppers
6 red jalapenos filled with cream cheese and served with your choice of dipping sauce
Hannah's Hen Strips
4 crispy chicken strips served with your choice of dipping sauce
Combo Platter
a heapin' mess o' wild bill wings, hannah's hen strips, poppers and waffle fries
Grilled Chicken
fresh garden greens with grilled chicken, cheese, tomato, onion and croutons
Chef Salad
fresh garden greens with ham, turkey, bacon, egg, cheese tomato, onion and croutons
Side Salad
fresh garden greens with a sprinkling of cheese, tomato and croutons
Salads
Sandwiches
Hollye's Cowboy Burger
all-beef patty with bacon, cheese and bbq sauce, topped with crispy onion straws
Big Bob Whitefish
crispy on the outside, flaky on the inside, served with tartar sauce on the side
Catfish
breaded or grilled, served on a bun with tartar sauce and your choice of side
Tenderloin
breaded or grilled, served with your choice of side
Chicken Breast
breaded or grilled, served with your choice of side
Club
loaded with ham, turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, cheese and mayo. served on white or wheat bread
All-american Blt
bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo on white or wheat bread
Sizzling Hamburger Steak
12 oz. of juicy seared black angus smothered in grilled onions served with baked potato and side salad
Bbq Grilled Chicken
lean grilled chicken breast drizzled in bbq sauce and served with your choice of sides
Jeff's Jumpin' Walleye
a hearty portion of pan-seared or deep-fried walleye served with cole slaw and waffle fries
Country Chicken Alfredo
fettucine with creamy alfredo sauce and strips of crispy fried chicken breast
Big Bob Whitefish
crispy fried big bob whitefish served with tartar sauce and your choice of 2 sides
Catfish Fillet
fried or grilled, served with tartar sauce and your choice of 2 sides
Taco Salad
a crispy tortilla bowl filled with fresh garden greens, spicy beef, cheese, onion, black olives, tomato, jalapenos and sour cream
Smelt
tillys famous smelt a basket full of steaming fried smelt served with waffle fries and cole slaw